Last reviewed November 19, 2026

Concrete or asphalt — what the published cost ranges actually say.

A comparison should start with the numbers the sources printed, not with a slogan. Dedicated HomeGuide pages put both materials higher than HomeGuide’s own overview table. Angi and Concrete Network add concrete figures that do not match HomeGuide either. We put the disagreement on the page and leave the choice, plus local climate and maintenance, to you and a contractor.

Installed cost ranges, side by side

SourceDatedConcreteAsphalt
HomeGuide driveway overview December 19, 2025 Table lists $4–$8/sf (and a 2-car-style total of $2,400–$4,800 in that table) Table lists $3–$7/sf (and $1,800–$4,200 in that table)
HomeGuide concrete driveway June 3, 2025 (title 2026) $6–$15/sf; 2-car $2,400–$8,600; quality tiers up to $20–$25/sf Not this page’s subject
HomeGuide asphalt driveway May 28, 2025 (title 2026) Not this page’s subject $5–$12+/sf; a 20×20 listed at $2,000–$4,800. Quality tiers on the page include $4–$9, $7–$15, and $12–$27/sf.
Angi concrete driveway Updated October 29, 2026 $8–$20/sf; national average $6,400; most $2,700–$14,500 Not quoted from this Angi page
Concrete Network Updated January 13, 2026 Plain $5–$8/sf; decorative $8–$21+ Not this publisher’s subject here

Do not average the two HomeGuide concrete rows. The overview table ($4–$8/sf) is lower than the dedicated concrete page ($6–$15/sf) and lower than Angi ($8–$20/sf). The overview’s asphalt $3–$7/sf is also lower than the dedicated asphalt page ($5–$12+/sf). We disclose both instead of inventing a blended “HomeGuide says.”

Same footprint, two planning bands

A 20×20 ft (400 sq ft) driveway, using only figures the sources attach to that size or to a per-square-foot band:

Those bands overlap. Asphalt’s published 20×20 range starts lower; concrete’s dedicated ranges run higher at the top end, and decorative concrete (HomeGuide mid-range $15–$20/sf, Concrete Network $14–$21) leaves asphalt’s typical band entirely. That is not the same as “concrete always costs more.”

Volume, if you are pricing the concrete itself: 20 × 20 × (4 ÷ 12) = 133.33 ft³ = 4.94 yd³ before waste, 5.43 yd³ with 10%. Material-and-delivery at $110–$195/yd³ is a smaller number than the installed totals — cost per yard, calculator.

What this comparison does not decide for you

Installed cost is only the first check. Climate (freeze-thaw, heat, oil stains), appearance, maintenance (resealing asphalt, sealing or repairing concrete), and how long you plan to keep the house all matter, and we will not invent lifespans or annual maintenance budgets we did not source for this page. Get at least a few local bids in the same scope (removal, thickness, base, finish).

State-level concrete notes (metros only): Texas, California, Florida. National concrete installed figures are collected on the driveway cost page.

Related

Concrete driveway cost · Concrete calculator · Gravel · Sources

FAQ

Is asphalt cheaper than concrete?

Often at the low end of published ranges, but the bands overlap. HomeGuide’s dedicated asphalt page (May 28, 2025) lists $5–$12+/sf and a 20×20 at $2,000–$4,800. Its dedicated concrete page (Jun 3, 2025) lists $6–$15/sf and a 20×20 at $2,400–$6,000. Angi (Oct 29, 2026) puts concrete at $8–$20/sf. HomeGuide’s overview table is cheaper for both materials and disagrees with those dedicated pages.

How much is a 20×20 concrete driveway vs. asphalt?

HomeGuide: concrete $2,400–$6,000 (standard to basic), asphalt $2,000–$4,800. Angi concrete: $3,200–$6,000 (average $4,600). Decorative concrete is higher.

Which lasts longer?

We did not source a head-to-head lifespan study for this page, so we will not invent one. Ask local contractors what they see in your climate, and compare warranties and maintenance, not just the first bid.